Holding the Line Review

Review: Holding the Line by Roy M. Griffis

Holding the Line is a paranormal YA military school story featuring ghosts, monsters, and boot camp life. This first book of The Long Watch combines weird horror chills and military boarding school hijinks.

Here at the Periapsis Press blog, we only post reviews of works we recommend, so you already know I enjoyed Holding the Line. I encourage you to check it out!

Disclaimer: We received a copy of this book from the author for the purpose of review. This in no way influences our opinions. (You can request a review here.)

This review contains minor spoilers.

Holding the Line Publisher Description:

Getting blown up wasn’t the worst thing that had ever happened to 18-year-old Danny Miller.

His mother had died so long ago, he could barely remember her. Now he lives with his alcoholic janitor father in the basement of the 150-year-old New Territorial Military Institute. Growing up at the prestigious, low-profile military academy, Danny had watched as the Territorial discretely provided a college education for the sons and daughters of politicians and royal families across the world, as well as the children of the rich and dysfunctional.

Beginning his freshman year at the Territorial on a “child of an employee” scholarship, Danny has a simple plan: graduate, leave behind his widowed drunk of a dad, and get the hell out of Wyoming.

That was before his home exploded. Before he met the sickly, spooky Tatiana who could See. Before the whispers in the night.

And that was before things got really weird.

Review:

YA Military School meets Paranormal Horror

Holding the Line takes place in a private pseudo-military school. The main character Danny Miller has lived on campus all his life, as his father is employed by the school, but now he is finally able to enroll. Readers of YA boarding school-based fiction will recognize some of the tropes, particularly the clandestine exploration of the spooky old Citadel building, but also dealing with bullies, sports, and first love.

The structure of the military-esque setting works to emphasize the things that don’t belong. These are small at first, strange events that get swept under the rug by almost-plausible explanations, but they ramp up. The climax goes completely off the rails in an epic battle against extraordinary foes.

Although Danny has lived on campus all his life, he has not uncovered all the school’s secrets. The supernatural events that pepper his academic year give small hints. The lore is meted out, nothing too concrete, but enough to give a rough idea of what might be going on: Ghosts, certainly. Aliens, possibly. Monsters, plenty.

Modern Weird Western

Where the lore is mysterious, the setting is vivid. The school is located in Wyoming, and the backdrop of the western United States gives the story a strong sense of place. In addition to the imposing scenery, the main characters occasionally ride horses and shoot guns, and the Lakota history of the region is touched on lightly.

While this is by not a traditional weird western, the setting is more than mere flavor. The sky, the mountains, and the dry plains all give a sense of something bigger than the characters. These geological features have endured generations and failing to understand them can put you at risk.

It reinforces the fact that there is Something Else out there that our heroes don’t fully understand and are woefully underprepared to meet.

New Adult Characters

 Danny is a bit pretentious—someone who knows a lot and enjoys explaining to the less informed. It is a character trait that I appreciated more in Narg of Griffis’ The Thing from HR. But it is not intolerable due to Danny’s tendency towards injury and the combination of other virtues such as loyalty, kindness, and heroism. In fact, when you learn that he wants to be a professor, it makes such perfect sense.

The YA romantic subplot feels unforced. The usual teen awkwardness, uncertainty, and enthusiasm make it engaging. Danny is intentionally aware of Tatiana’s history and doesn’t want to be someone who uses her weaknesses to take advantage. His determination to be a good person within the relationship is admirable, while the baggage they each carry feels raw. It is worth noting, that although the couple are both adults (this is not high school), there is no “adult content” within their relationship in this first book. Instead, we get a very sweet, innocent sort of love story—not pornified and yet not asexual either.

Ordinary Values

Early in the story, a few rich kids gather on a patch of grass carefully marked “keep off.” The Major reprimands them:

“To the personnel of this school, that little piece of land is sacred. This is where we inter the last remains of our fallen friends. Staff and students both have sacrificed their lives and more for this good earth.” When they point out that there are no gravestones, he replies, “We know that only honored dead rest here.”

The narrative continues, “Then he stopped talking. He’d provided them the information they needed, and so he simply ceased to speak.”

In this way, Holding the Line doesn’t push a contrived theme, but throughout there are simple statements of values.

From Danny’s reserved stance on sexuality—informed by the importance he places on Tatiana and his relationship with her—to the family Christmas he plans to spend with his friend, the small details of an ordinary life are held up as meaningful, without guile. Danny’s tendency to over explain the meaning of words is not present here: there is no convoluted justification or attempt to push the reader into a particular opinion.

Check Out Holding the Line!

Holding the Line is a sincere YA school story and a spooky weird horror tale combined in a satisfying read. I look forward to reading more of The Long Watch!

Did you enjoy Holding the Line?

Hit the “Recommend this Book” button at the top of the page or Comment below with your own review.

We (and other readers) want to hear your thoughts!

The Thing from HR by Roy M. Griffis Book Cover
Try another adventure by this author!
Dierock88 by S.A. Oliver updated book cover
Read more young hero vs strange monsters!

Subscibe for Updates:


Loading

Related Posts:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copyright © 2020 Periapsis Press